Design Smackdown – Form vs. Function

Free Tips on a well decorated home

Okay, a discussion about Form vs. Function is not exactly a design smackdown, but it’s a good jumping off point for a conversation. I was recently doing some research in quotes on design and realized that two icons of design – Steve Jobs and Marcel Wanders –  had very different and very interesting views on design.

 

Form vs. Function Steve Jobs on Design Apple iPhone

 

Form vs. Function Marcel Wanders quote on design New Antiques Black chair

 

Of course, there is the famous adage Form follows function which is often attributed to Frank Lloyd Wright but was actually coined by his boss/mentor architect Louis Sullivan:

“Whether it be the sweeping eagle in his flight, or the open apple-blossom, the toiling work-horse, the blithe swan, the branching oak, the winding stream at its base, the drifting clouds, over all the coursing sun, form ever follows function, and this is the law. Where function does not change, form does not change. The granite rocks, the ever-brooding hills, remain for ages; the lightning lives, comes into shape, and dies, in a twinkling.
It is the pervading law of all things organic and inorganic, of all things physical and metaphysical, of all things human and all things superhuman, of all true manifestations of the head, of the heart, of the soul, that the life is recognizable in its expression, that form ever follows function. This is the law.

I love a good philosophical discussion, until my head starts to hurt…

This all follows a conversation among designers on Facebook about a kitchen design project that a fellow designer just had showcased on a large website. (No names will be shared to avoid embarrassing anybody). The kitchen in question is a recent remodel of a very small kitchen and it’s a lovely, lovely job. The finishes, mix of textures and styling for the photos is impeccable. It also appears that they carefully planned out the minimal space for maximum efficiency. I’d love to walk into that space every day. But, the thing is – it’s missing a very important and standard element that one usually finds in a kitchen. There is no ventilation hood over the range. Ventilation hoods are required in some jurisdictions and not in others, so one assumes this designer wasn’t legally required to have a hood. There are windows in the space, so perhaps that’s why ventilation isn’t required. It also doesn’t appear that the range has integrated downdraft ventilation.  So, this begs the question: is it good design if the space is pretty and presumably answers all the functional needs of the occupant yet is lacking a normally very important aspect of a kitchen space – the ability to remove grease particles, steam and food smells from the kitchen and house itself?  And, even though it’s probably legal where the project is, do publications which are showcasing “good design” have an obligation to uphold the highest standards and only show projects that are subjectively beautiful AND objectively functional?

Form vs. Function Dana Wolters Interiors kitchen design with light stained cabinets, counter stools, white counters, cooktop
Dana Wolters Interiors kitchen design

This kitchen above was designed by the amazing Dana Wolters of Birmingham Alabama. You’ve probably seen it before – it’s a very popular image on social media because it’s so swoon-worthy.  And what do we have – subtle ventilation built in above the cooktop.

Form vs. Function Promenade Design + Build Small kitchen with brick wall hood and black stove light green cabinets
Design by Promenade Design + Build

And this gorgeous NYC property by Promenade Design + Build. Small is beautiful! In addition to the amazing ventilation hood, the shelves are not only decorative, but also low enough to be functional as well.

Form vs. Function Linda Merrill French country kitchen cooktop green painted cabinets copper ventilation hood

Form vs. Function Linda Merrill French country kitchen cooktop green painted cabinets copper ventilation hood
Linda Merrill Decorative Surroundings French Country Kitchen with hand painted cabinets.

My own condo kitchen makeover included a simple, utilitarian vent hood (which is a code requirement where I am). A tiny space that got a big makeover a few years ago.

So, what are your thoughts on form vs. function? I personally feel that as a designer, my job is to integrate both into every design. If a space isn’t functional, if it doesn’t work as it should, if it doesn’t make the occupants lives easier, then there is something lacking. I often will harp on functional needs with clients (who are usually more focused on aesthetics) and try to keep decisions based on current needs, future needs (such as resale) as well as beauty. Because if it’s not beautiful, if it doesn’t touch the soul in some way (maybe not to the level of Mom’s cat, but you know what I mean) then it’s also lacking. We need both. From Jobs’s perspective – design is all encompassing – form and function are necessarily intertwined and one cannot be without the other. From Wanders’s perspective – functionality is the starting point, the obvious first step onto which beauty and meaning are layered. This view means, of course, that they are separable.

I’d love to hear your views on form vs. function.

xoxo Linda Would you like my Favorite Tips for a Well-Decorated Home? Click here!

6 thoughts on “Design Smackdown – Form vs. Function

  1. I spent 20 years in kitchen design and would NEVER, EVER allow a kitchen to be without an exhaust system. If I needed to convince a client that it was necessary, I would offer my one hour lecture on why. In my own kitchen, in a 1500 sq ft mid C home, not an open plan, but with very good air circulation, the hood forms the plenum and there is a 1000 cu ft fan on the roof. I’d like to send you a photo, but it won’t attach to the comment. I’ll email it to you.

  2. I agree! Does not matter how good it looks, if it doesn’t function it’s worthless. Our 1800’s farmhouse had a kitchen reno with the same problem before we bought it. Looks great- NO function. Unfortunately- it’s all going to be gutted and done right. That’s fine with us as our new kitchen will be the hub of entertaining for our attached gallery. A good designer factors in a harmonious balance of both form and function.

  3. You are spot on Linda! Maybe the kitchen with no vent hood was designed for an owner that only eats out or take-out. You’d be surprised how many people truly “don’t cook”. Speaking of hoods, mine has the buttons on the underside so my fingerprints don’t show in front and I poo poo the modern hoods with glass dome covers – “you’ll never get the grease off” 🙂 Happy Weekend to you!

I'd love to hear your thoughts!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: